← Back to Articles

[DEMO] Add On or Move? How to Decide If a Home Addition Is Right for You

Comparing a home addition with buying a new house.

[DEMO] Add On or Move? How to Decide If a Home Addition Is Right for You
The short answer

If you love your neighbourhood and your home mostly works, an addition usually makes more sense than moving. If you need a completely different layout or location, moving may be the better fit.

Everyone needs more space at some point. If your roots are firmly planted in your current home, moving might not be the right answer. A home addition can give you the room you need without leaving.

At a glance

Home addition vs. moving: how they compare
FactorHome additionMoving
NeighbourhoodStay where you areStart over somewhere new
LayoutDesigned around how your family livesLimited to what's on the market
DisruptionLiving near or through constructionSelling, buying, packing and moving
Extra costsDesign and constructionSelling and buying costs, plus moving
Long-term valueMore livable home, appealing to future buyersDepends on the new home

Option A: Build an addition

An addition lets your family keep living and growing in your current home while adding much-needed space, like a guest bedroom, a room of their own for a growing child, a sunroom, a mudroom or a main-floor suite.

Advantages

  • Keep your neighbourhood, schools and community
  • Space designed around your routines
  • Can make the home more appealing when you eventually sell

Trade-offs

  • Construction at home for the length of the project
  • Kitchen and bathroom additions cost more because of added fixtures and appliances
A bump-out addition provides space for a bright new living room
A bump-out addition provides space for a bright new living room.

Option B: Move

Moving can make sense if your current home can't be adapted to what you need, or if you want a different location.

Advantages

  • A completely different home or location
  • No construction while you live there

Trade-offs

  • Selling, buying and moving costs add up
  • Finding a home that truly fits can take months

How to decide

  1. Audit how you use your current space. What are the biggest pain points?
  2. Write your wish list. How do you see the new space working for you?
  3. Talk to your financial advisor about what you can comfortably invest.
  4. Ask family and friends about their renovation experience.
  5. Interview a few contractors to find one who understands your vision.

If most of your answers point to loving where you live, an addition is likely the better path.

Frequently asked questions

Will a home addition add value to my house?

It makes the home more livable for you and more appealing to the next owners. Larger kitchens and updated bathrooms are especially attractive to buyers.

Where do I start?

Start with an audit of how you use your space today and what you wish it could do.

Fall In Love With Your Home All Over Again

Distinctive home renovations in Kitchener, Waterloo, Cambridge, and Guelph for 70 years!

Stay connected with us